Short-term care in Skilled Nursing Facilities (SNF), Medicare and VA benefits

Funny Dog Meditation

SNF sounds like Sniff—-Ommmmm….Sniff Sniff

I’m left with more questions after looking into this but here goes.  Short-term care is defined as 90-100 days or under.  Medicare Part A (Hospital) stops paying for care at SNFs at day 101 and beyond:

For Medicare, you pay

  • Days 1–20: $0 for each benefit period in 2013.
  • Days 21–100: $148 coinsurance per day of each benefit period in 2013.
  • Days 101 and beyond: You are personally liable for ALL costs.

Looking at some information on the Medicare website, I see lots of gotchas.  You need a qualifying 3-days (in a row) inpatient hospital stay, not observation (inpatient) stays which are considered outpatient days.  Got that? Orwellian to be sure. Oh, and you have to stay out of the hospital or SNF for 60 days to have the benefit period renew.

The VA has about 132 nursing home units but also contracts with with “Community Nursing Homes” (CNH) for short-term rehab and long-term care.

The VA charges this after 21 days:

  • Inpatient: Up to $97 per day (Community Living (Nursing home), Respite, Geriatric Evaluation)

**Copayments for Long-Term Care services start on the 22nd day of care during any 12-month period — there is no copayment requirement for the first 21 days. Actual copayment charges will vary from Veteran to Veteran depending upon financial information submitted on VA Form 10-10EC.

That’s cheaper than the cost of non-VA nursing care charges according to a U. S. News article if you are in a higher Priority Group or run out of Medicare benefits.

According to Medicare Manual (50.1.1), VA enrolled veterans–with dual Medicare/VA eligibility–have an advantage if they need therapy in a non-VA SNF.

The VA may authorize up to six months of care in non-VA SNFs for veterans requiring such care after transfer from a VA hospital. Services furnished pursuant to a VA authorization do not count against the 100 days of extended care benefits available in a benefit period. Where a veteran remains in a SNF until VA benefits are exhausted, extended care benefits could begin under Medicare. Such benefits begin with the first day after the VA benefits are exhausted, provided a physician certifies that the individual still requires skilled nursing care on a continuing basis for a condition for which the patient received inpatient hospital services or which arose while the patient was still being treated in the facility for such a condition. The 3-day qualifying hospital stay and 30-day transfer requirements of the law must be met as of the time of entrance to the facility….

Generally it is advantageous for Medicare beneficiaries who are veterans to have items and services paid for by the VA where possible, since in most cases the VA has no deductible or coinsurance requirements. Also, services paid for in full by the VA do not count against the individual’s maximum number of benefit days or visits available in a Medicare benefit period. 

For veterans who do have a VA co-pay, this is also good to know:

NOTE: Medicare can reimburse veterans for (or credit toward Medicare deductible or coinsurance amounts) VA copayment amounts charged for VA authorized services furnished by non-VA sources.

The VA website is vague on details because VA social workers have to get involved and more involved financial information is required.

My late father suffered a major stroke in his seventies.  After his hospitalization, he was moved to a skilled nursing facility until all of his Medicare and “MediGap” benefits were exhausted (about three months).  Then, ready or not, he was transferred into my mother’s unskilled hands and the semi-skilled hands of home health aides.  He still needed therapy services. However, when he used up his allotted time at the SNF, he had to first be re-admitted to a hospital as an inpatient. To accomplish this, my assertive mother had to gain a physician’s cooperation.  My mother constantly battled with Medicare over it’s restrictive rules.  Dad made progress, used a walker, but aphasia prevented him from conversing.  He lived ten more years.

Eligible veterans have more options. Suppose a veteran (dual-enrolled) found himself in bad straights and needing rehab five days a week.  What should he do? It would be probably be less expensive to get transferred to a VA hospital, and then placed in a contracted “Community Nursing Home” with therapy services. You can also request the VA pay for a different SNF/CNH if you have a preference.  If more rehab is needed later, one can tap into Medicare benefits when (or if) the VA benefits run out.

This VA health benefits calculator “HB Explorer” may shed some light on this matter for individual veterans.  Click on “nursing home placement” link after making all entries. http://hbexplorer.vacloud.us/

This brief video (right menu) “Choosing Short-Term Care” impressed me with the importance of visiting SNFs before you need them–especially those with VA contracts.   Medicare has a nifty Nursing Home Compare online app..  http://www.medicare.gov/nursinghomecompare/search.html

I entered my zip and up popped 12 local nursing homes (showing several categories with 1-5 stars).  I could then compare any three and drill down for more gory details.  Most enlightening.

Posted in Guest authors, VA Medical Mysteries Explained | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

HCV SVR IN THE REAL WORLD

downloadVA is always trying to suck in a new cohort of victims for their triple drug cocktail called Victrelis. They bought in hard with about three trainloads  early on in hopes of knocking out HCV as we know it in the living Vets population.  It was a win-win for all. No active acute disease equals 0% noncompensable so this was a no brainer. Only problem seems to be those rapscallion Vet drug/alcohol abusers who are dragging down the success rate. 

VA’s recipe for a repair order is cook the books, bay-bey! Tell them it 80-90% so they’ll all jump in. Who cares if you’re 72 and a triple non-responder? This drug’s for you. Now along comes someone who decided to add up columns A, B and C and find out who’s been naughty and who’s been nice. Seems VA was selling underwater real estate. Go figure.

Posted in HCV Health, VA Health Care, vA news | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

CAVC–NICELY v. SHINSEKI-DRIVIN’ THAT CLAIM, HIGH ON PRO SE

downloadIt behooves us all to be humble when we read this. I honestly believe this is the product of a simply misunderstanding. Mr. Nicely was depending on his American Legion service organization representative to carry the water. Oddly, here he is up at the big house on Indiana Ave. and there’s no Amleggy-ons to be seen anywhere. Something’s amiss. Fortunately, being pro se, he’s going to get another piece of pie and a cup of coffee and another heapin’ helpin’ of VA hospitality. Nobody wants their name on this locomotive. You can almost envisage the headline in the Huntington, W.V.  fish wrap “Wheelchair bound Vet with psychiatric disabilities  given bum’s rush at VA-‘Not our problem says VA spokesman’.”

Here’s the condemned’s rationale for his appeal. If I parse it correctly, it seems he may have injured his back in basic. It also says he’s currently in a wheelchair which is some serious smack talk. VA takes notice if he starts getting diarrhea of the piehole up at the big house.

I’d love to be a fly on the wall down at Amleg Hqtrs.

Nicely

And here’s the kid gloves.

Order

Knowing that when you arrive at the CAVC unrepresented, you usually get 40 or 50 solicitations for legal services from attorneys, I find it difficult to see how our Veteran Parley here got this far without a winter’s worth of paper to burn in the wood stove.

Posted in CAVC/COVA Decision, VSOs | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

NEGATIVE OBJECTIVE CORRECTED

SizemoreJE01c

Jim Sizemore and A-26

Member Frank opened up an old wound this morning when he mailed me this WP article published yesterday. I find it hard to believe it was a mere forty three years since I departed the Kingdom of Laos on the C-46 Klong flight from Wattay to Udorn. I also see the article descended into a political donnybrook of the worst sort in the comments section. I added my own.

I am saddened that anyone, be it from the infamous Westboro Baptist Church or any other individual or entity, would sink so low as to dishonor the commitment of a fellow American who volunteered to serve in any war. Anti-war, Monday morning quarterbacking seems to be in good form lo these four decades later.

So, with joyous heart for the families of Major James E. Sizemore and Major Howard V. Andre, I welcome home their husbands and fathers.

purcellI remember well those years from 1965 on as I watched the friends of my father, many with children I attended school with, fail to return. Those who did survive were often a hollow shell of their former selves like Bob Purcell. Captain (at the time) Purcell was a Thud driver for the 4th Fighter Wing. Bob ‘s son and I attended St. Mary’s when we lived at Seymour Johnson AFB in Goldsboro, N.C. from 1962 to 1964. When my parents were out of town, I was farmed out to stay over with them. I remember the dachshund they had that liked to poop at night indoors. Midnight trips to the bathroom were a careful undertaking.

66_134_221_117_122167We moved to Langley AFB, Virginia in 1964 and I never saw them again.  My father left to go to RVN slightly over a year later in June 1966. His replacement, Bob Worley, was shot down and died several months after Dad returned in 1968. I went to Hampton Roads Academy with his son Rob Worley in those years. Again, reassignments caused us to part company never to see each other again. And then I went to war.

As time moves on, we’ll eventually recover more lost souls. However, in Laos, those will be few and far between. When an aircrew augered in over the fence, rescues were dicey propositions. Often, an Air America chopper pilot was the first one on the scene.  With virtually little or no weaponry, they would often swoop in for a rescue long before our own ARRS choppers were wheels-up over at Long Tieng. As for a nighttime air rescue, I never heard of one. They might put up a gunship with flares overhead if they knew the location of a crash but this was rare. Armed recon at night in an A-26 painted black as a sack of cats did not often result in a lot of recoveries.

207310My fondest hope will be to see Major Park Bunker’s remains returned to his family in my abbreviated lifetime. Capt. Bunker was not an adventurer like most of his fellow FACs. He didn’t fit the mold. He actually was cautious and hidebound-one for doing it by the book- but had no qualms about getting down in the weeds. He augered in 30 December 1970.  Capt. Bunker was what we called a “negative objective”.  His O-1 was clobbered by groundfire and he actually landed in one piece. Knowing full well that there were no POW camps for us in Laos and that repatriation was not in the cards, he fought to the end with little more than a CAR-15 and his .38 cal. M&P revolver. With no air support, his fellow FACs watched from altitude as he and his Hmong GIB were killed. When this happened, the AF was rather a stickler that no more air assets be expended in recovery. Sadly, the forlorn radio message went out announcing Negative Objective. Thus Capt. Bunker joined the Sizemores and Andres in a long pantheon of KIA BNR (body never recovered). I’m sure that at some time on the 9th or the 10th of July, 1968 that negative objective was announced for Majors Sizemore and Andre. It always was.

This is why we celebrate so heartily when one of our fallen finds his way home. We talk of “closure” and giving the family a meaningful plot to visit at a cemetery but it is far more than that. The ethos of the military has always been that you do not leave your fallen on the field. People seem to think this is a Marine affectation. I can assure you it is not. In Laos, it was more often the rule rather than the exception that we lost our pilots-day or night.

It is enervating to see the eventual return of these brave men who volunteered for what they knew was a very dangerous job when they could do their 100 missions from a “normal base” in RVN or Thailand and not take inordinate risks.

Capt. Bunker’s photo above bears little resemblance to the man I met.  I enclose a picture of the Captain below which more will be familiar with. Welcome Home, gentlemen. I’m glad your remains were not desecrated.

laos1

Posted in Inspirational Veterans, Vietnam War history | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

VA to Vets: Health Care Act talking points

aca va

This week, the VA mailed my DH a shiny FAQ and a form letter about the health care law. They are “sell sheets” for the VA.  Could the VA be concerned that too many veterans will drop out of the system in favor of the private marketplace?

Consider the benefits they write: no monthly premium, deductibles or enrollment fees!  But wait, there’s more.  The VA offers 1,700 places to get care!  And, “most veterans have no out-of-pocket costs.” Is that a true statement?  The VA website says that “copays…may be required from some Veterans for treatment of nonservice-connected conditions.”  The co-pay to see a specialist is $50.00 per outpatient visit.

If a veteran stays with the VA, they CANNOT get the tax subsidy. (If someone qualifies for Mediaid, they will not get a tax subsidy because they will pay very little for health care.)

VA health care benefits depend on gross income and net worth.  (LINK)

The whole priority group scheme and means test is confusing.  If you are in Priority Group 7, you will have a co-pay and your income is determined by the Geographical region income limit.  If you are Priority 8 (high income) you may not be eligible for any health care but there are some exceptions (read here).  To determine if you are in 7 or 8, pick the fiscal year, pick your state’s county and family size and hope you’re not above the VA’s income thresholds for health care.   (Service in the Republic of Vietnam should put a veteran in Priority 6 but some are still charged co-pays.  What’s up with that?)

Either/or scenarios. Veterans who live more than 30 miles from a VA hospital might be better off with private insurance so they aren’t stuck with an emergency room bill should they have an emergency that the VA won’t cover.   On the other hand, if a veteran needs a lot of expensive medications, the VA looks attractive in comparison to private plans.  And if their current VA health care team is top-notch, it makes good sense to continue with them.  The VA is also better about issuing needed medical equipment than, say, Medicare. 

The VA does not want veterans to flee en mass.  Question:  Can I cancel my VA health care coverage?  The answer is a warning: “Yes, however acceptance for future VA health care coverage will be based on eligibility factors at the time of application, which may result in a denial of health care coverage.”  There’s that favorite word again, denial.  

This is a not very veiled threat.  But, if tens of thousands of new veterans decide to enroll in the VA, with few cancelling, Congress may push out more middle-class income veterans.  It’s not really about one’s service to the country.

 The number of Veterans who can be enrolled in the health care program is determined by the amount of money Congress gives VA each year. Since funds are limited, VA set up Priority Groups to make sure that certain groups of Veterans are able to be enrolled before others. instead of expanding funding to care for them.

Going forward, the VA is going to have to compete with the convenience that regional hospitals and local health care providers offer.  The safest best option, for veterans who can afford to forgo the tax subsidy and pay a premium, is to stay enrolled in the VA (hopefully with your “spot” grandfathered in) and pay for private insurance through the marketplace even if it’s not a premium plan.  That way you won’t face debtors’ court (or prison!) should you get hit by a thunderbolt far from VA-land.  (In any case, family members may qualify for a tax subsidy even if the veteran stays enrolled in the VA.)

thunderstorm-29949_1280

Image: Public Domain on Pixabay.

Ed. Note: Kiedove has done her homework on this one. If they had not tried to kill me (four times) I might be amenable to their brand of medicine. I believe VA suffers a “treat each item apart from the whole human”- e.g. you are service connected for disease A so come on down and we won’t charge you anything but if you even mention symptom B related to a non-service connected item, you can be billed for it. I dislike having to defend a ride to the hospital to get VA coverage. I know I’m Priority one and it is immaterial yet I have to submit the documentation each time to help my local Fire Dept. recoup the cost of the ride from the VA. Otherwise they wait two years to get the dough.

Posted in Guest authors, VA Health Care, vA news | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

FACEPLACE

halloween

This one says it all. Must be one of those Happy Halloween things early.

 

Posted in Humor, VA BACKLOG | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , | 3 Comments

KIDNEY STONES

images

5 mm diameter

Sorry if it appears I went on vacation. I actually did. Just got out of the hospital this morning. I crumped last Wednesday and was in the ER by Friday morning. It felt like the ugly return of the small bowel obstruction. The pain and agony was worse than giving birth. The urologist even confirmed that. Women have said they’d rather give birth than have one.

No food since Wednesday night and of course, no sleep. I only lost 8 lbs. Maybe I should publish my new miracle five-day kidney calculus and water only diet guaranteed to whack 8 lbs. off or your money cheerfully refunded. That and idiot lab technicians to come in at all hours wanting to take your vitals and more blood. Thank goodness it was a real hospital this time. Going to the VA after you’ve been to real hospitals is such a let down. It’s like Marlboros. Once you come back, you’ll never switch brands again.

I’m now roaming the house eating anything in reach. Call me Hansel. There’s a trail of bread and cookie crumbs behind me because I’m so sleepy. Sorry I let you all down. Will get back in the saddle tomorrow. My kingdom for my extendo-grabber to look at the upper shelves. This must be what it feels like to have the munchies.

Posted in ASKNOD BOOK, Humor | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 10 Comments

DRV REQUESTS REMUNERATIONS FOR BENZENE CANCER

Drop tank 11

Government officials in Ho Chi Minh city, Democratic Republic of Vietnam, today formally announced they will be seeking remunerations from the United States for Benzene pollution and the concomitant resulting cancers associated with it in numerous Northern Vietnamese fishermen. Apparently, cancer rates among the indigenous fishermen along the Mekong is grossly out of proportion to world statistics. The incidence of Acute Myelogenous Leukemia (AML), Myelodysplastic Syndrome (MDS) and Non Hodgkins Lymphoma exceeds what scientists could rationally explain were it strictly a function of diet. Researchers have analyzed all the metrics and remain baffled as to the source of the Benzene.  Meanwhile, in Damascus this morning…

Drop tank 2drop 3drop 4drop 5drop 6

Posted in Humor | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

VETS OVER THE HILL

attachment

Some of you guys still want to play macho tough guy and prove you still have your six pack abs like Ranger school. In order to help you, member WGM has spotted this new Texas technique guaranteed to take you back to your old, former days of tough-as-nails physique.

Posted in All about Veterans, Humor | Tagged , , , , , , , | 1 Comment

VA–RELAX, IT’S A BLIND STUDY

download

Blind study QR code

I’ve never been one for conspiracy theories or wiping my fingerprints off guns I handle. But… the other day an obvious piece of junk mail arrived from the VA. This one was labeled the Million Veteran Baseline Survey. Now, keep in mind that we couldn’t even induce VA to study the correlation between jetguns and HCV transmission other than to get one of those idiotic “It’s plausible-just like getting hit by lightning.” responses out of them for the last decade. Therefore anytime VA gets into the business of “collecting” data on us and it’s purported to be “confidential and secure”, I start by examining the premise for it. And just so we aren’t confused here, the Veterans Health Administration computer is fully accessible by Veterans Benefits Administration raters and VA examiners. 

Let us begin. Each document has a QR code. That in itself is of no concern to me. What raises the hair on the back of my neck is reporting to the VAMC and having them do a friendly sit down, review your metrics and have you submit a blood sample. Somewhere along the line, you will be asked to produce your VA ID card. They are not going to simply let a horde of self-proclaimed Vets through the front door and start drawing blood without determining whether you were in the military. I’m sorry. It just doesn’t work that way at the VA. VA will know who you are long before the blood is drawn. Again, so much for anonymity.

On the introduction page, the questionnaire says by responding, you are doing this voluntarily by “consenting to participate and agreeing to have a one time MVP study visit scheduled”. Seems innocuous on its face. The cover letter addressed to you has the same QR code on it as the survey. But in the cover letter, the commitment is more nuanced. They ask that you “allow ongoing access to medical records by authorized MVP staff”. And in true mission creep, they also tell you by signing up, you “agree to future contact by MVP staff“. Nowhere on the baseline survey does it suggest or imply this is anything more than a one-time shot in the dark.

Some of you will remember that our august institution that watches out for us has a propensity to draw blood and be less than forthcoming about what’s swimming around in the test tube. Witness the large numbers of Vets who discovered in 2012 that they had been tested for HCV (and found positive) as early as 2006 and were never told. Do any of you believe that this is a research tool to better the lives of Vets? This is the same outfit that fought tooth and nail to avoid complying with the Nehmer Agent Orange class action suit and to this day still is recalcitrant and obdurate about complying with the rules and regulations relating to the “herbicide”.

The last sentence on the cover letter says “If we do not hear from you within the next few weeks, we may contact you again”. And again. And again until you comply.

So, what is in this little survey? First of all, let’s analyze this from the Mel Gibson standpoint to satisfy the criteria for a good conspiracy. Read through the questionnaire and you see the tenor of the questions is focused almost exclusively on Vets from the early sixties to the present. There are no questions about Lewisite which is prominently mentioned as a risk for military members in the latter part of WW2 or Korea. No talk of radiation exposure from Hiroshima or SHAD testing.  The brunt of the inquiry seems focused on Vietnam-era diseases rather than Southwest Asia ones. HCV, Parkinson’s, ALS, MS, Crohn’s, Peripheral neuropathy, IHD, mental disorders and prostate cancer. No questions about Camp Le Jeune and how many glasses of water a day you drank there…

Were the questionnaire more general and have more varied choices, I wouldn’t feel it was narrowly focused on one era of Vets. Obviously, the thing that stands out is harvesting all this info when we have never been able to persuade them to do a baseline study on HCV. I have watched with consternation the increasing numbers of claims and filings for HCV as more of you fall ill. It takes a long time for dense-minded men to acknowledge something is amiss. When they do, they go in expressing bravado to a doctor making his job infinitely more difficult. They also fail to link some of their ills to longstanding issues. I felt I just worked hard and this was the cause of my aches and general malaise. I’m not a doctor. Framing houses is not for the weak of heart. You don’t need to be muscular but it helps. Thus if you become inordinately tired from doing it day in and day out, it could be confused with simply being tired- even at 35. Vets are not a complaining bunch for the most part. The “gitterdone” Force is strong in us. We don’t go see a doctor until parts start falling off.

The questionnaire is framed such that a computer could digest this and come up with your name, rank, airspeed and tail number without a lot of conjecture. The second question is “What is your DOB?”  Add in that you are going to sit down with “MVP staff” and discuss your answers one-on-one with them and it adds up to an interesting fishing expedition. Mental health, income, queries about ethnicity, marital status, et cetera are disconcerting to say the least. An example is the query about your education. Were this to be disseminated (hell, any of this) by the VBA, a decision on your application for TDIU could easily be denied based on what you state as an income or how you view your current health. Your answers might somehow conflict with some you have submitted as evidence for a current claim. Without being forthcoming on where they get their information, VA can deny you based on what you have provided. So much for a double blind study where you remain anonymous. Ain’t going to happen, GI. For the record, there is no such thing as double-blind at the VA unless you are -quite literally-blind in both eyes. If your doctor calls you for a telephonic consultation, it’s recorded. Every visit to the VAMC is meticulously documented. I went to the Dental clinic for a teeth cleaning and at the end asked the lady not to put the flouride goop on my teeth as it wreaks havoc on my liver. Sure enough, in the VISTA records Colleen annotated “Pt. states he does not want fluoride prophylaxis. Says ‘it wrecks my liver’.” Why would they even bother to enter your exact comment?

Looking clearly at my biometrics asked for in this query, I would have no problem identifying myself based on the questions asked were I to have complete, unfettered access to the VHA computers. And who is asking for this information? Well, duh.

Lastly, the questionnaire proposes to query one million Vets. Last time I checked, there were 27 million of us. What about the other twenty six? For the record, there are less than one million of us genuine, red-clay-between-the-toes Vietnam Veterans left alive (670,000) so the aimpoint of this seems transparent. I know the 2010 census revealed that thirteen million of you red-blooded warmongers were there in Cu Chi and Qui Nhon raping and pillaging the villagers. Seems Stolen Valor is alive and well at the VFW now after three drinks and that it’s finally”okay” to be a Vietnam Veteran (Welcome Home, Bro). Perhaps this study was to designed to ascertain just exactly how many of you are are pulling the census takers’ leg.

The innocuous questionnaire:

2013-09-18 0902512013-09-18 090251_22013-09-18 090251_32013-09-18 090251_42013-09-18 090251_52013-09-18 090251_62013-09-18 090251_72013-09-18 090251_82013-09-18 090251_92013-09-18 090251_102013-09-18 090251_112013-09-18 090251_12

I find it interesting that I received this. I would ask any of you who receive it to comment here as to what era you served in. If you do not mind terribly, please add if you served in country. I don’t see this as our nonadversarial, good old Veteran-friendly VAMC striving to provide a more pleasurable visit. Anything VA does anymore is suspect in my book.

P.S. Here’s the attached letter. Note the circled sentences.Million Vet q&A

Posted in All about Veterans, HCV Health, HCV Risks (documented), research, Vietnam Disease Issues | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | 16 Comments