BVA–Win…BUT Pension, NOT Compensation

Here’s a decision that grants the Vet SC for Hepatitis with nothing more than jetguns as a risk factor. You say: Hey! All well and good. Then the Idiots at Military Order of the Purple Heart(MOPH) don’t take the next obvious step and link all his other obvious hep illnesses as secondary to the Hepatitis. This is financial suicide for the Vet because he can now ONLY collect the VA pension instead of VA Compensation AND SSD. The majority of this Vet’s symptoms are attributable to Hepatitis. It’s a no brainer. He’s unemployable and no one disputes that. The hangup is that the BVA and the VSO collude, come up with a sub par Hepatitis rating that doesn’t encompass his true disabilities, and then give this VET the bum’s rush to Pension @ 100%. That’s a weak $3 K/mo.(or $36 K/yr.) assuming he’s married w/o children. If he were getting it as Comp., he’d probably get another $1500.00 (SSD)on top and be in the $54 K/yr.tax free bracket. Conspiracy? Who knows? Call it the Bracket Racket. I used the MOPH chuckleheads my last time out and they said I’d never get Hepatitis and especially not my PCT- ever. Of course , they also said if I had any tattoos I was sunk and we know that advice is bogus. I finally gave THEM the Bum’s Rush and won without all their valuable help. This advice is not for everyone- mind you. There are some very sharp VSOs out there who are invaluable to your legal strategy. I just haven’t been lucky enough to meet one yet in my 20 year quest for Justice. This is also another one of those “be careful what you ask for” claims. The Vet/VSO specifically asked for a “non-service connected” pension instead of a Total Disability for Individual Unemployability(TDIU). There is a big difference here- about $18,000.00 a year difference and the totally tax free nature of a compensation rating with SSD. I personally think he could have made his case for TDIU. That is not chump change. Be careful Veterans!

http://www.va.gov/vetapp08/Files5/0837526.txt

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA–2007— HCV & PCT 2ndary to HCV

Finally, VA and BVA are starting to see that PCT (Porphyria Cutanea Tarda) is present in a lot of HCV cases. So is Cryoglobulinemia, DM2, Fibromyalgia, Chronic Pain Syndrome, Chronic Fatigue Syndrome(sore throat forever, anyone?), peripheral neuropathy, and about 10 others I forgot. Check this out for 2007. Clarksburg, W. V. I have seen several good HCV decisions come out of there on appeal and get SC. Vietnam Veterans of America is perhaps one of the Better VSOs around in my book. Use them if you can for your claims. Avoid the rest. But always supervise your SO. They aren’t perfect- don’t expect them to be. That’s why you’re here reading this anyway, isn’t it? To be prepared like a boyscout? It’s a Jetgun claim of sorts, for lack of a better risk factor. Treat it like that.

http://www.va.gov/vetapp07/Files3/0724747.txt

You will probably recognize VLJ Cheryl Mason’s name(she is mentioned in several other decisions here in ASK NOD). She has made some smart, clean, well thought out decisions on Hep C with the Vet getting SC where it was clear that he /she deserved it. She has never resorted to tortured logic that ends up with a train wreck of phrases that contain the “it is at least as not likely as not that the hepatitis in question is not related to the hepatitis we are talking about here.” This decision is basically a ” Well. Its clearly obvious we don’t know what caused it, so it could be Jetguns. There doesn’t appear to be any other big, bite you in the ass reason.” Thank you Judge Mason, on behalf of thousands of HCV positive Vets. We wish we could have you as our Judge every time. $100 says she isn’t a Blonde. As we all know, peroxide causes brain damage…

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA–2005–3 NEXI AND AN APPEAL

This was handed to me by our Fearless Leader Harry. Ask Nod is a group enterprise and everyone is encouraged to submit helpful info. Harry is perennially up to the task in that regard. He pointed out that those helpful young men down at the VARO in Denver tried unsuccessfully to imply that this Veteran was an intravenous drug abuser with a long history of such. Unfortunately, the RO didn’t have any supporting evidence for this shocking accusation and the ploy failed. How many attacks on Vets’ morals succeed? Who knows. The good news is the Vet won this one. Nothing makes us happier than to publish these stories. Herewith, for the Veteran reader’s edification, another success story involving jetguns:

http://www.va.gov/vetapp05/Files3/0518599.txt

Sometimes, after shooting themselves repeatedly in the foot, they manage to get it right. Having not one, but 3 doctors testify on his behalf, VLJ James L. March ruled in favor of the Vet. He probably didn’t get a Christmas bonus that year (2005) and was warned to “knock it off” by his co-judges around the water cooler in the hallway because he was giving them all a bad name. I apologize. That is just conjecture on my part, not fact. I guess what I find amazing is that Government employees lied and twisted the facts to impugn the Veteran’s credibility and medical history and were not arrested and imprisoned. Since I don’t have a subscription to VA CONSPIRACY magazine, I always find it amazing when I discover things like this. Am I naive? Naw.

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA— 2009 JETGUN W/O ADDMITTING IT

Read them and weep. Decision is brand new. Its dated 2008 but that is a typo. Just posted to the BVA site this month. It’s in with the 2008 decisions as they haven’t started a 2009 search category.

http://www.va.gov/vetapp08/Files5/0841645.txt

You will notice that they did not specifically state ” more likely than not via jet gun”. So it is still not a true “win” for jetguns, but more a he-said, she said and the Vet just happened to bring his own nexus to the party. VA didn’t. More proof that if you arrive with a nexus that is plausible and not “in your face” incredible, have your medical stuff to back you up, then you win. VA is lazy. If you have the nexus, they usually agree with it.

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA–2008 JETGUN WIN ( and no Rebuttal)

This is another “You win because nobody really remembered to get a good anti-nexus together to rebut you”. The Vet didn’t have any Bozo no-no stuff to point at, so they gave him a pass. Is this the BVA decision making process we hope to see again and again in the future? Who knows. It was late in the year (November 08) so its hard to say if this is some kind of “precedent” of sorts or if the Vet was just a Senator’s Son. It was filed under a hardship clause,too, which indicates the Vet was broke or very ill. Perhaps it was an early Christmas present:

http://www.va.gov/vetapp08/Files5/0837526.txt

This Vet is getting screwed out of his SSD because he should be getting TDIU or 100% P&T for Compensation purposes, not Pension purposes. Trust VA to screw it up. Anybody in Pittsburgh recognize this guy? Call him and tell him to convert to Comp. and call SSA for a Disability rating.

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA–Jetguns/Tats-not DUI

Yep. Here’s another one of those “Well, it probably was jetguns, but we can’t say that so we’ll call it tattoos”. One thing they didn’t blame it on (but tried) was a DUI. Yes, gentle reader, you read that right. Driving under the Influence is now a risk factor, apparently. Prior to today I was unaware of this. Just exactly how this applies to Hepatitis C (or any other flavor) was not clearly explained. Actually I’m being a little oblique here. There is an apparent correlation to alcoholism, but that too, is rather ambiguous. Get drunk. Wake up with Hep. Simple. God. I hate that when that happens. Its like when you reach into the garbage disposal to get that spoon and your wife leans over and cuts on the switch and…

http://www.va.gov/vetapp08/Files2/0813838.txt

I’m not sure if Veterans are aware of this but this is not the first time VLJ Jordan has come down on the side of a Vet regarding a HCV ruling. Too bad we can’t chose our Judge for our Docket. This guy is Hot.

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

BVA–Jet Gun Winner- Sort of

This was just posted several hours ago on the BVA appeals site. As usual, it does not set precedent as a panel decision of the CAVC would, but it shows the thinking of the Veterans Law Judges who decide these cases. In this instance, the Nexus letter was dead on and the Judge realized it. End of controversy, n’cest pas? I have abbreviated some of the legalspeak to get to the meat of the argument. If you wish to read the unredacted version go to the BVA site>:
http://www4.va.gov/vetapp10/files2/1016262.txt

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

BVA–We have a winner!

While this decision doesn’t set precedence, we hope it is a harbinger of better things to come. This Vet won his claim by carefully preparing it. he has good nexus letters from several doctors who attest that the jetgun is the culprit. He does have combat blood exposure and claims to have had a transfusion, but that evidence is not conclusive. This VLJ in essence is giving him SC based on the jetgun. And we thought all those pictures of guys in skivvies waiting for their date with the gun in basic were for naught. This Vet was smarter. He claims he’s in the picture. What the Hey! He won.Onwards through the fog. Vote for Oat Willie. One small step for Hepkind.

http://www.va.gov/vetapp10/files3/1024254.txt

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

BVA–Another winner

We at asknod are hoping this decision becomes normal for Vets with HCV. You will notice the Vet arrived without a nexus, but was provided one by way of an IME. These usually don’t go well for the Vet, but this one did. Bravo for the BVA!

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

BVA–Navy Jetguns

Ah, yes. We certainly hope this type of decision gets to be the norm. Notice that the doctor uses the liver transplant info as a timeline indicator for how long the Vet was infected. This is becoming more accepted by VA now with Metavir or Child’s ratings of your biopsy. This may become the yardstick for proving the age of the infection.

http://www4.va.gov/vetapp10/files2/1016262.txt

In a November 2009 statement, an IME indicated that, the  Veteran served in the military, during three time periods  between 1955 and 1976, and received numerous vaccinations, at  least some by air-gun injection; that he was diagnosed with  hepatitis C in 1995; and that, prior to that time, he denied  any behaviors, exposures, or risks that would transmit  hepatitis C.

Therefore, the exact date of hepatitis C infection is  impossible to determine, although acquisition of the  infection in the 1950s or 1960s would fit with the history of  progression to end-stage liver disease in the 2000s.  The IME  added that the transmission of hepatitis B via air-gun  injections has been well documented in the medical  literature.  Transmission of hepatitis C has not been, never  been, clearly documented to be related to use of such  devices, although the VA’s own Medical Service stated in 2004  that transmission of hepatitis C in this way was  “biologically plausible.”  The IME agrees with this  statement.  Therefore given the information available to him,  the IME believes that “it is highly likely that the  [V]eteran acquired [h]epatitis C between the 1950’s and  1970’s, encompassing the time of his military service, and  given the absence of any other know[n] risk exposures or  events it is as likely as not that this exposure was due to  the use of jet gun injections.”

Pretty straight forward, huh?

Posted in Jetgun BvA Decisions | Tagged , , | Leave a comment