| Hi, I have been battling with the VA since 2004 on getting my ratings where they should be and getting a rating for my HepC, but it has been a long road. first things first. I guess I am total dumbass because this has been wrong from the start. In 1973 when I was wrongfully discharged as a drug addict and unfit, no one told me to go to the VA and file a claim for my ulcer rupturing in service. No one told me I could file a negligence claim against the Army for allowing my ulcer to get to the point that it did rupture. I asked for a medical discharge but recieved a General under Honorable and let out 6 mos early. When I was at home a guy from the ODVA(Oklahoma) came to my house with an award letter granting me 30% for my ulcer and 10% for my hand that was broken when I got shoved down a flight of stairs in AIT. He also had a appointment letter for a C&P exam at the Oklahoma City VAMC. He also had a back pay check for four months of back pay.Now can anyone tell me how I can get a rating, and award letter, and a check before there is even a C&P exam? Does’nt the C&P come first to assess the level of disability? Clearly the VARO in Muskogee decided that for me. I was totaly ignorant about the way things work. Especially the VA. I had no idea of how they operate, but I still don’t know how they can issue a rating without first giving me a C&P exam.No one wants to comment on it, no one wants to hear about it. I have tried several times to get someone to listen to me but I get nothing. The DAV files these claims for me and then they seem to disappear. In 2004 I filed claims for HepC, ulcer disease, my broken hand, and negligence for neglecting to inform me that I am positive for HepC. They knew in 1999 I was positive yet I was not told or offered treatment until 2004. I have been unable to get a NEXUS from any doctor. So my Hepc claim is sitting there with its ass hanging out without a nexus. So that means I will proably get denied right. The doctor I had right before I moved back to Arkansas refused to even talk to me about service connection let alone get a Nexus. The private doctor I had refused to give me one because he did not have enough time to sit and go thru all that paperwork.
So if this isn’t bad enough to deal with just exactly who can give me a Nexus. My last denial for HepC was because they said I was a first responder at my last job and was exposed to blood. Which is a total lie because I never even put a band aid on anyone other than myself. I never gave mouth to mouth. Who or where can I write to and tell my story that will get some action? It has been a long time since I got my award, but the way I got my award is wrong. How can the VARO make a decision without a C&P? I would like to see the initial claim so I can know who signed my name to it. Doesnt everyone who files a claim have to do so in person and sign the form? Just wondering what a person to do? __________________ ————————————————————————————
|
||||
| KC54-
Where to start? This will be a long one. I read this this morning and started digging for info during the day. I have several answers and lack some info on other parts with no access to your records and your rather abbreviated descriptions. Here goes…
Let’s start with the ODVA showing up at your house. I assume they found you because that was your address of record on your 214 when you separated? If not, I’m stuck. If that is true, it proves that you were entitled to this at discharge and they converted it to a VA rating. They just didn’t get it accomplished before giving you the boot. You would not need a C&P for it if you came out of the service with it in 73. That is called presumptive- i.e. you manifested it within one year of discharge. In your specific case, you manifested it before discharge-same difference in their eyes.
As for the Disappearing American Veterans VSO you signed up with, do not feel pregnant and alone. It seems that is the trademark of all those outfits. Once they set the hook with the POA signature, they evaporate. You do understand that the VSO gets a small retainer from VA for “representing” you? The POA sets that in motion. It’s a jealously guarded secret as to what amount trades hands, but the amount isn’t tivial. Perhaps now you can understand why they are always out beating the bushes enlisting new “victims” to refill their bank accounts. It’s like a Bernie Madoff Ponzi scheme.
Back in those days they could pretty much run over you with a tank and get away with it. Nobody told me I could file a claim with VA when I got out in 73 either. Like you, I was also given a General with 7 months off. Mine was for antisocial personality w/ passive aggressive tendencies after coming back to the World from 2 years in-country. The biggest “tendency” I had was to dive under something when a car backfired. I understand now it was PTSD. They gave me a choice- take the personality disorder or admit I was a queer. As I’m not, I opted for the former.
Now for the nexus. You have come to the right place for that one. You can ask the VA for more time to obtain one if the claim is on appeal. Have you filed an NOD? We don’t seem to have enough info to paint a picture of your judicial posture with what you have provided. For a nexus, we will ask you to contact Dr. Ben Cecil. He has provided nexus letters for many of the HCVets with a high rate of success. Below is his web link:
We’re glad you finally made it here. Perhaps you would have had more luck sooner if you had found us earlier. Maybe not, knowing how the VA operates. The important thing is you have a filing date of 2004. Protect it and do not let any deadlines pass. Dr. Cecil will help you. You will need your service medrecs and any other more current ones especially any VA VISTA records. If you have your military records, that may be helpful if you need to refute this drug business. Dr. Cecil will want to see that. We strongly suggest you read the posts above this to acquaint yourself with the VA process if you are not sure where you’re going. Read the Introduction and all the others through the Percentage of Wins. There is much there that can help you learn this game. Your VSO was probably not familiar with this side of the claims process.
We personally do not know how the VA deals with negligence lawsuits. You would have to file that under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA) and have 2 years from the day it occurred to file- not one day more. That claim has to be filed on a Form 95 (see attached below). I don’t know all the rules as I haven’t done that one yet. VA noted on one of my C&Ps for my back in 89 that I had what appeared to be gastro problems that might turn into IBD. I came down with Crohns in 95. I didn’t find this out until 2009 when I got my C-file. Too late. We have heard this story of VA testing Vets for HCV and then not telling them that the results are positive. You are not the first. Something stinks about this and we are sure it isn’t just HCVets. We’re willing to bet it encompasses a lot more Vets with heart problems and much worse.
Who to call? Good question. This looks like a job for our illustrious defender of Vets- Senator Patty “tennis shoes” Murray of the State of Washington who is the head of the Veterans Affairs Committee in the Senate. That would be my guess. Her VA gopher is Kim Brown and he is a part of the GOB network in Seattle. We know he plays golf and racquetball with some of the senior fellows at the VARO. He talks the talk to you but I have seen some of his private email messages from my C-file and he does not walk the walk for us. He actually joked with the Congressional interest dude at the RO and said: “Yeah. That NOD guy thinks he’s gonna die and he’s hitting on me to get his AO claim settled sooner. Jez. What does he want? You guys just gave him $38 K in back comp. pay. So what can I tell him?” That, KC54, is reality. We are lower than whaleshit in their eyes. They give us lip service and little more. My guess in Arkansas is Claire McCatskill. She’s your senate gopher so you’re gonna want to make waves on her beach. This isn’t my forte. We like to fix Hep. claims and leave the politics out of it unless its personal.
You can always private email me and give me the skinny on the claim if there is something you don’t want out here. Otherwise, let ‘er rip. We hope this gives you more to work with than when you posted. I hope you weren’t over at some other Veterans site getting bogus info on hep claims all these years. I hate that when that happens. What we can guarantee is you won’t get 400 different answers on the subject with inane answers like “That’s what happened to my Cousin Leroy. He told ’em it was from AO and he won”.
Lots of luck on this and let us know what you need. We belong to the Pay it Forward for other Vets school.
|
Actaully I did submit my own Nexus, but they keep denying for some lame reasons. The first of course being no record of it during service, even tho I was given eight units of blood during surgery to fix my ulcer. I also spiked an un-explained fever of 105* in ICU recovery that no one is looking at. The second denial was that I was a first responder at my last job and was exposed to blood. But I never even put a band aid on anyone.
This will be my third attempt to get SCC for HCV. If I get denied again I do not know what my options if any are. But for the most part I have submited what is required and have not let any deadlines pass without response. Hopefully I will know something in the next few days or weeks. In a few days it will be sixty days since it was handed to DRO. But in the meantime I enjoy what I have learned here and I appreciate your response to my querys. Will definitly be posting the reults as soon as I hear from the VARO. And I will be contacting that Dr for help with a Nexus if it isn’t too late.__________________
whitewidoww@yahoo.com
| Whoa Nelly and feed the horses! You mean to say that DHS can’t use my SCC from the VA as income? I know that I don’t have to pay taxes but the DHS has always counted my VA income. If this correct I need to find out about this because we have been denied food stamps and medicare in both OK and AR. I must find where it states that my income from the VA does’nt count at the DHS.And yes I recieved the blood during surgery to fix my ulcer while in service. It ruptured while I was in the motor pool doing my assigned job. I was so sick I could hardly stand but only two days prior I was told at the infirmary to quit drinking and return to duty.Man I have some work to do here. I have to find out who to talk to about getting my DD214 upgraded to honorable.I have already been to a video conference with the BVA in Muskogee OK in 2008 and it has been remanded. This is what I am waiting on. But I am writing to this Dr Cecil right now for a Nexus. Or am I too late since this is on remand? do I still have any appeals left after this ruling. I feel I will be denied, this has all been a shock to my system.
__________________ ——————————————————————————– |
||||
| Shoot, bubba. This one should have been in the bag years ago. If you had a transfusion for even one pint before 1992 in service, this should have been paying since the filing date of 04. This is why you have to have a nexus. If you have a scanner or a fax, get me on the PM and send the original denial to me. Something odd is afoot here. VA must be trying to paint you as a druggie and use that for the denial (yep. you were shooting up hashish.) |
whitewidoww@yahoo.com
Like I was saying I have been very depressed and just gave up on everything until I talked with you here. Now I have some new meds and am feeling much better and I feel a little less confused.
I don’t understand what part of this surgical report they don’t understand. It clearly states that I was given blood and that I spiked a post op fever of 105* that was unexplained. It has been hell ever since. Can I submit a statement on my own behalf? I would like for my wife to make a statement also as to my illness’s. Man I am awake now and I am not going to take this anymore. It’s time to get mad and let them know I am not going down any time soon.__________________
whitewidoww@yahoo.com
| ————————————————————————————Sir, let me be the first to commiserate with your plight. You are not the first to discover your legal representation is not what you bargained for. I cannot even begin to tell you how much this hurts us here at Nodquarters to hear about the shortcomings of your VSO. This seems to be the modus operandi all too frequently these days. Whether there is a disconnect in the training of service officers or gross indifference to the needs of Veterans is immaterial. The end result is still an abomination.
When we entrust our claims to others, be they lawyers or VSOs, the clear expectation is that they will be prosecuted in a responsible manner. There is the unwritten assumption that the person or organization who offers this service is versed in the procedure. In fact, not just versed, but well versed. After all, this is all they do for a living. From 8 to 4 every day all these SOs do is type up the proper forms and contact the appropriate personnel. I know from my own experiences that it probably takes a year or more to absorb the very minimum to be a functional SO. Anything I can’t pull down out of my drop down brain screen can readily be looked up in the CFRs. Mostly, its like driving a car. Once you learn, you don’t have to remember which side of the street to drive on. You know what red, yellow and green signify.
The requirement for a nexus was first announced in Caluza v. Brown in 1995. For the mathematically challenged that was 16 years ago. Just in case that didn’t absorb into the VSO culture, another case enunciating the same exact legal concept was issued in 1999. This was Hickson v. West. Once again, for the truly impaired, Shedden v. Principi (2004) went all the way to the Federal Circuit. Short of publishing it in Playboy, it is virtually impossible for service officers or a Veterans Service Organization to claim ignorance of this seminal requirement for all claims short of ones where the evidence is so dispositive as to make a nexus letter superfluous (see Savage v. Gober 1999).
Nevertheless, we now discover your SO, in keeping with a long tradition, has withheld this little secret. I believe you are the second one this week we have encountered that has been similarly disenfranchised.
As for verbally rescinding Power of Attorney, let me assure you that it has no legal force. It must be in writing with your signature to pass muster. Similarly, contacting the VARO and announcing this verbally over the phone again has no legal validity. One cannot expect VA to make a tape recording of this statement and sandwich it into your C-file. In fact, one cannot expect very much of anything from the VA other than the promise of making a complete hash of your claim.
With that said, let us examine the actions of VSOs. Some are unarguably better than others. As a collective entity, their success rate is not stellar. Their popularity and win/loss ratio will never rise to the level of F. Lee Bailey. What perhaps concerns us more is the proclivity to “disremember” the very regulations that are necessary to win. We really hesitate to use the noun “collusion” as “in collusion with the VA to deprive Veterans of their rights”. Although the evidence seems to point to it, we just can’t believe there could be a conspiracy of this magnitude. Let’s weigh the evidence and then perform the “Benefit of the Doubt” dance.
1) VSos are afforded space right outside the doors of most VAROs rent free.
2) VSOs are provided funds by the VA upon issuance of a durable Power of Attorney to represent the Veteran before said VA.
3) VSOs seem to have a good working relationship with VAROs and have intimate access to raters and other personnel on a regular basis-what we call an open door policy.
4) VSOs present themselves as being indispensable in the presentation of your claim before the VA. Indeed, they tout themselves as the ONLY way a Veteran can get a fair shake.
5) VSOs have been known to dissuade Veterans from filing a claim based on the premise that the chances of winning are slim. They also have a propensity to advocate for judicial appeals with no chance of success. Absent a solid foundation for your claim, any later attempts to resurrect it based on the same flawed premise is judicial suicide, yet these paperhangers engage in this day in and day out with utter abandon.
6) VSOs tend to keep YOUR cards close to THEIR chest until the cause is lost. They then proclaim their mea culpas and don sack cloth and anoint their head with ashes. All this is a well-orchestrated show for the Veteran’s benefit. Granted there are genuine service officers who really care and are effective. I do not wish to demean them as a class. Actions often speak louder than words and the results most of us receive at the hands of these “experts” is appalling.
In sum, if you as a Veteran can find an educated, experienced SO with your best interests at heart and a small caseload, you may be pleasantly surprised at the outcome. Absent even one of these four prerequisites, you will be inevitably disappointed. What’s worse is that this individual has no control over your claim when it leaves to go to D.C. on appeal. That responsibility is delegated to a higher ranking member of the organization you will never meet who could be functionally illiterate but well-connected in the VSO. This is often where your claim runs aground. In a VSO, your claim is nothing more than a number. You, as a flesh-colored, breathing human being do not exist.
You are always free to submit a statement in your own behalf as is your wife. Limit it to the effects you can ascertain by your five senses and avoid playing doctor. Watch Judge Judy and mark her words regarding hearsay evidence. You wife cannot opine on your illness back to its inception unless she has been there from the beginning. Complete your statements with this phrase to ensure it is considered “under oath” or sworn testimony:
“I certify that the above statement is true and correct to the best of my knowledge.”
Now, I would have you weigh the six items above and tell us if you would give the benefit of the doubt to religiously prosecute your claim to anyone situated cheek and jowl with your sworn adversary. I’d sooner believe in the tooth fairy and the Sandman. Santa Claus is a given.
|
||||
| Well said and understood, I believe I did the right thing this morning. I now who is my rep there and I have a teleconference with him on tuesday morning. I want to talk to him before I do anything. I am just waiting for Dr Cecil to reply to me. I have the surgical reports ready and what little medical records I was given from the hospital in Germany. Hell most of it looks like someone just scribbled this stuff. Total chaos and even my Dr could’nt read the file. But my surgery reports are very clear and states I was given 7 units of blood during surgery and also noted the post op fever. Yes I have often wondered why I decided to let the DAV handle this for me. I was succesful up to this point in getting my claim upgraded from 20 to 40 on my stomach but I had to go thru some stiff manure to get it done. I was told by my PC at the VAMC that I was suffering from what is called dumping syndrome. But I could not find a written diagnosis of it in my files anywhere, nor where there any records of going to see nutritionists. I also complained to my PC about bowel leakage and having to go to the toliet 15 minutes after I ate. No written record of any diagnosis yet they would sit there and say yeah, that what it is all right, and then record nothing. Some of my consults begin with, today I saw Mr Robert Vaught a 56 year old well defined and nourished male. Now let me paint you a picture, I am 6’3” tall and wheigh 131 lbs, I have a 29 inch waist and you can count every bone in my chest and ribs, I sticks for legs and muscle wasting in my hands and feet. There atcually is no other way to go except to represent ones self in this theater. I will know more come tuesday or like you said I am gonna blow an ass gasket. LOL Thanks for waking me up.__________________ whitewidoww@yahoo.com————————————————————————– I didn’t have to wake you up. By coming here you must have been starting to wonder if there wasn’t more to this than met the eye.My old family doctor (and friend)of 15 years is valuable for decyphering medrecs. Sometimes I take Vet’s stuff in and ask him what the gaggle of abbreviations are. It’s like waving a set of new plans under a Builder’s nose. They have to look at them. VA has some that are more probative. WHNS= well healed no sequelae; NAD= no acute distress; WD= well-dressed; NCNS= no complications, no sequelae; ETOH = anything to do with booze; NPN= non-prescription narcotics; and there’s more. They all seem to have one thing in common. “You’re fine, son. Good to go. Perhaps you’d like to join our group therapy on Thursday evenings? Perhaps you’ve heard of them. Narcotics Anonymous? We also have alcohol abatement therapy groups, PTSD groups, Anger management groups, Kumbaya, My Lord groups. Yep. We got groups.” |
| ———————————————————————————
|
||||||||||||||
| I have been reading a lot of decisions in the vets favor and a large part of those that got a new rating or won their claim had no VSO. It always says appealant. Why do these guys even exsist is my question. Obviously if a vet follows these guidelines and advice they can come out on top istead of bending over. If I don’t hear what I need to hear tuesday morning I will set another set of wheels in motion. __________________ whitewidoww@yahoo.com—————————————————————————- |
||||||||||||||
|
